The difference between talking about what happened, surviving the trigger, and understanding why your mind sounded the alarm
I recently came across a therapist discussing complex PTSD and why, in his opinion, many people diagnosed with it spend years in treatment without getting better.
His argument was that some people being treated for complex trauma may actually have undiagnosed borderline personality disorder (BPD), and therefore they aren’t receiving the treatment they actually need.
He referenced psychiatrist Joel Paris and his book Myths of Trauma: Why Adversity Does Not Necessarily Make Us Sick.
There are parts of that argument I disagree with.
Current research does not support simply treating complex PTSD and BPD as interchangeable diagnoses. There is significant overlap between them, but research generally supports meaningful distinctions as well.
But there was another part of this discussion that stopped me.
The therapist said that some people spend years and years talking about their trauma and don’t get better.
Sometimes, he said, they get worse.
And that’s where I had to stop and say:
That part happened to me.
Not because therapy was worthless.
Not because talking about trauma is harmful.
Not because CPTSD was secretly something else.
And certainly not because nobody can recover from complex trauma.
I recovered in ways I once didn’t believe were possible.
But looking back now, I can see something that was missing for me for a very long time.
I spent years talking about what happened to me.
I learned ways to cope with what happened inside me when I was triggered.
What I didn’t understand yet was how to ask:
Why does my mind believe this particular thing is a threat in the first place?
That question changed everything.
Therapy Did Help Me
I want to make this very clear because I don’t believe the answer is:
“Therapy doesn’t work.”
Therapy helped me.
Talking helped me.
Being able to tell someone what had happened and hear that my feelings were understandable helped me.
There is something incredibly important about finally being able to speak about an experience you may have carried silently for years.
There is also value in learning grounding techniques, breathing exercises, emotional regulation and other coping strategies.
Those things can help bring us back when our bodies and minds are overwhelmed.
But eventually I realized that, for me, those tools were answering one particular question:
How do I get through this trigger?
I needed to ask another one:
Why is this triggering me?
And then another:
Why does this keep happening?
And finally:
What does my mind believe is happening right now?
That was the beginning of a completely different part of my healing.
I Was Managing the Alarm Without Understanding Why It Was Ringing
Imagine a smoke alarm going off.
You learn how to tolerate the sound.
You cover your ears.
You breathe through it.
You remind yourself that you’re safe.
Eventually the alarm stops.
Those tools mattered because they helped you survive the noise.
But then the alarm goes off again.
And again.
And again.
Eventually I stopped asking only:
How do I calm myself while this alarm is ringing?
I started asking:
Why does this alarm keep going off?
That’s the distinction I wish I had understood years earlier.
I didn’t simply need to become better at tolerating my reactions.
I needed to become curious about them.
The Trigger Wasn’t Always the Actual Problem
This became one of the biggest realizations of my healing.
Something could happen today and absolutely unravel me.
Someone’s tone changed.
Someone became angry.
Someone misunderstood me.
Someone didn’t respond.
Someone criticized me.
I felt excluded.
I walked into a room and suddenly felt overwhelmed.
I received an email that made my stomach drop.
From the outside, someone might reasonably think:
That’s what you’re this upset about?
Sometimes even I thought that.
But eventually I discovered something.
I wasn’t necessarily reacting only to what had just happened.
My mind had connected what happened today to something else.
And that something was connected to something else.
And something else.
The reaction made very little sense if you looked only at the present event.
It made considerably more sense once I understood everything my mind had associated with it.
The Rubber-Band Ball
The best visual I have for this is a giant rubber-band ball.
Imagine that early experiences become rubber bands.
One experience teaches something.
Another reinforces it.
Another appears completely unrelated but creates the same feeling.
Another reinforces the same belief.
Then another relationship reinforces it.
Another environment reinforces it.
Another rejection.
Another argument.
Another misunderstanding.
Another moment of shame.
Another experience of feeling responsible for someone else’s emotions.
Over years, those experiences wrap around one another.
Eventually there are hundreds of interconnected strands.
Then something happens today.
Someone pulls one rubber band.
To everyone else, it looks like one tiny event.
Inside your nervous system, the entire ball tightens.
And suddenly the memories start coming.
This happened when I was a child.
This happened in my marriage.
This happened at another job.
This happened in another relationship.
This always happens.
Nobody understands me.
Something must be wrong with me.
Why does my life keep repeating itself?
That is what complex trauma felt like inside my mind.
The thing that happened today wasn’t necessarily the entire reason I was hurting.
It pulled on something much bigger.
Children Don’t Have to Understand What They’re Learning
This is where I think childhood becomes especially important.
Children are learning constantly.
Not only through what adults intentionally teach them.
They’re learning through relationships.
Reactions.
Tone.
Facial expressions.
Repetition.
Conflict.
Safety.
Affection.
Rejection.
Repair.
And what happens after something goes wrong.
Imagine a parent rushing around the kitchen.
The timer is going off.
They’re overwhelmed.
They turn around and trip over their child.
Something spills.
And the parent snaps:
“Why are you always in the way?”
The parent may not intend to emotionally injure their child.
Maybe they’re stressed.
Maybe they’re dysregulated.
Maybe that is how adults spoke to them when they were young.
Maybe five minutes later they’ve forgotten they even said it.
But the child’s developing mind still experienced the interaction.
One isolated incident doesn’t automatically create complex trauma.
But now imagine variations of that message appearing repeatedly:
You’re in the way.
Stop crying.
You’re too sensitive.
Why are you making such a big deal out of this?
Why can’t you just behave?
Look what you made me do.
Stop bothering me.
You’re old enough to know better.
The child isn’t necessarily consciously deciding:
“I am now going to develop an unhealthy belief about myself.”
The child is adapting.
And underneath those experiences, the developing mind may begin learning:
I cause problems.
Other people’s emotions are my responsibility.
When someone is angry, I need to fix it.
My emotions create problems for other people.
I shouldn’t need anything.
If someone is upset with me, I may lose the relationship.
I need to watch everyone around me so I know whether I’m safe.
This is what I call invisible learning.
Nobody necessarily sat the child down and taught those lessons.
But the lessons were learned anyway.
The Environment Changes. The Learning Can Remain.
Now imagine that child becomes an adult.
She’s 35 years old.
Her boss sends an email:
“Can you stop by my office when you have a minute?”
Her coworker receives the same message and thinks:
I wonder what she needs.
But her stomach drops.
Her heart starts racing.
Her mind starts searching.
What did I do?
Did I make a mistake?
Is she upset with me?
Am I going to get in trouble?
Do I need to explain something?
She starts mentally preparing her defense before she even knows why she’s being called into the office.
Why?
The email itself isn’t traumatic.
The boss may not even be angry.
But the message pulled one of those rubber bands.
Someone wants to talk to me.
becomes:
Someone may be unhappy with me.
which becomes:
I probably did something wrong.
which becomes:
I’m going to be blamed.
which becomes:
I need to explain myself.
which connects all the way back to something the mind learned long ago:
When someone is upset, I am responsible and I need to fix it.
Suddenly the reaction makes sense.
Not because the boss’s email was traumatic.
Because the brain interpreted the present through something it had already learned.
This Is Where “Just Get Over It” Misses Everything
People on the outside see the email.
They don’t see the rubber-band ball.
So they say:
Why are you so upset?
You’re an adult.
Your childhood was decades ago.
Everybody’s parents make mistakes.
You’re too sensitive.
Stop overthinking everything.
Just let it go.
And sometimes the person experiencing it can’t explain it either.
They know their reaction feels enormous.
They know logically that something doesn’t add up.
But their body is sounding an alarm that feels completely real.
That’s why telling someone:
“You’re safe.”
may be helpful without necessarily changing the underlying pattern.
The deeper question becomes:
Why doesn’t my brain believe I’m safe?
Talking About the Memory and Understanding the Pattern Aren’t the Same Thing
This is where my experience with therapy becomes much clearer to me.
I could talk about the boss.
Then I could talk about my marriage.
Then childhood.
Then another relationship.
Then something else somebody had done.
Every story was true.
Every feeling was real.
But I could spend years discussing individual rubber bands without understanding that they were all wrapped around the same ball.
That’s what eventually changed.
Instead of only asking:
What happened?
I started asking:
What does this remind me of?
What feeling came first?
What am I afraid is about to happen?
Where have I felt this before?
What did I believe about myself then?
What am I believing about myself now?
Is the present actually the same as the past—or does something about it merely resemble the past?
And eventually:
Is what my mind learned actually healthy?
That question changed my life.
Healthy Versus Unhealthy Became the Missing Lens
For most of my life, I didn’t have the framework I have now.
I looked at situations through:
Who was right?
Who was wrong?
Who hurt me?
Why did they do this?
Why does this always happen to me?
Why can’t anyone understand?
Why can’t I get past this?
Then something shifted.
I started looking at my experiences through a much simpler lens:
Was this healthy or unhealthy?
And suddenly things that had seemed impossibly complicated started becoming clearer.
Some things other people did were unhealthy.
Some environments were unhealthy.
Some relationships were unhealthy.
Some things I had learned were unhealthy.
And some of my own behaviors were unhealthy too.
That last part mattered tremendously.
Healing wasn’t simply identifying what everyone else had done to me.
I had to recognize what I had carried forward.
The explanations.
The fear.
The hypervigilance.
The assumptions.
The need for reassurance.
The unhealthy choices I had sometimes made while trying desperately to protect myself.
Understanding where something came from gave me compassion for myself.
It didn’t remove my responsibility for changing it.
Then I Started Unwinding the Ball
Once I could see those connections, something remarkable began happening.
The rubber bands started coming off.
Something would happen that years earlier would have completely unraveled me.
And…
nothing.
Or I would feel something briefly, recognize it and move forward.
Sometimes I would actually stop and think:
Oh my gosh. I would have reacted completely differently to this before.
Those moments became some of the greatest evidence of healing I’ve ever experienced.
Because nobody had erased my memories.
The past hadn’t changed.
The people involved hadn’t necessarily apologized.
I hadn’t forgotten anything.
I had changed.
And therefore the meaning of the memory changed too.
The Memory Became a Memory
This is one of the hardest parts of healing for me to explain.
There are memories that once hurt tremendously that can come into my mind today and cause almost nothing.
I remember them.
I know they happened.
I can understand why they affected me at the time.
But they don’t pull the entire rubber-band ball anymore.
They are simply memories.
And sometimes I look back at something that once triggered me terribly and realize:
That wouldn’t hurt me today.
That doesn’t mean the earlier pain wasn’t real.
It means the lens through which I’m processing the memory has changed.
Before, the memory might have meant:
There it is again.
Nobody loves me.
I’m always rejected.
I’m the problem.
People always leave.
Something is wrong with me.
Today the same memory can mean:
I understand why that affected me then.
And then it passes.
The memory didn’t disappear.
The alarm did.
Coping and Healing Were Different Stages for Me
This is why I no longer see coping skills as bad or useless.
They weren’t.
Sometimes we need something that helps us make it through the moment.
Grounding matters.
Breathing matters.
Emotional regulation matters.
Talking matters.
Support matters.
Sometimes survival itself is the immediate goal.
But eventually, for me, another question became necessary.
Grounding told me:
You’re safe right now.
Healing made me ask:
Why didn’t my brain know that?
Grounding helped me return to the present.
Healing made me investigate:
Why did I leave the present in the first place?
Those aren’t competing ideas.
They were different parts of my journey.
Where Joel Paris Enters This Conversation
Psychiatrist Joel Paris has questioned whether complex PTSD is sufficiently distinct from other forms of psychopathology, particularly borderline personality disorder.
There is genuine overlap between CPTSD and BPD, especially involving emotional regulation, relationships and self-concept.
But they should not simply be treated as interchangeable diagnoses.
Current research generally finds meaningful differences between the two, even while recognizing that they can overlap and can occur together.
BPD does not require a trauma history.
ICD-11 complex PTSD, on the other hand, includes the core symptoms of PTSD along with disturbances in emotional regulation, self-concept and relationships following exposure to extremely threatening or horrific experiences.
Paris also makes another argument that I find more interesting:
Trauma alone should not automatically become the explanation for every psychological difficulty someone experiences.
And on that point, my lived experience actually leads me somewhere surprisingly similar.
Because eventually I stopped looking only at:
What happened to me?
I started looking at:
What developed inside me around what happened?
What did I learn?
What did I begin believing?
What adaptations did I make?
What relationships reinforced those beliefs?
What environments kept them alive?
What choices did I later make through that lens?
And what am I still carrying that no longer belongs in my life?
That is very different from endlessly retelling a traumatic event.
Where I Part Ways With the “It’s Really BPD” Explanation
The therapist whose video led me into this discussion argues that some people diagnosed with complex PTSD may actually have undiagnosed BPD and therefore spend years receiving trauma treatment without getting better.
Correct diagnosis absolutely matters.
If someone has BPD, they deserve evidence-based treatment for BPD.
If someone has CPTSD, they deserve treatment appropriate to their symptoms.
And if someone has both, both deserve attention.
Where I become uncomfortable is when an important diagnostic question turns into a broad explanation:
People with complex PTSD aren’t getting better because they’re actually undiagnosed borderlines.
Current research doesn’t justify reducing CPTSD to BPD.
And my own experience certainly doesn’t allow me to determine what diagnosis belongs to another person.
But my experience does allow me to say this:
I spent years getting help without finding the piece that ultimately transformed my understanding of myself.
The missing piece for me wasn’t another label.
It was understanding the pattern.
I Didn’t Need to Become Better at Tolerating Everything
There is another piece of this discussion that matters deeply to me.
Treatment shouldn’t automatically mean making someone better at tolerating every environment.
There were times when my nervous system treated things as dangerous that weren’t actually dangerous.
Healing helped me recognize that.
But healing also helped me recognize something else:
Some environments actually were unhealthy for me.
Those two things must be distinguished.
Sometimes healing says:
You’re safe. You don’t have to run.
Sometimes healing says:
You are allowed to leave.
There is a difference between avoidance driven by fear and discernment that comes from a healthier mind.
My life became quieter as I healed.
My circle became smaller.
I stopped believing I was obligated to remain in every relationship simply because someone was family, because we’d known each other forever, because someone expected me to attend, or because walking away might disappoint someone.
I don’t see that as evidence that healing failed.
For me, some of it was evidence that healing worked.
And Then There Was God
There is one part of my healing journey that I can’t separate from everything else.
God.
I remember reaching a point where I was completely exhausted by the repetition.
The same pain.
The same patterns.
The same kinds of relationships.
The same reactions.
The same memories.
The same question:
Why does this keep happening to me?
And eventually I fell apart before God.
I essentially said:
I don’t know what I’m missing. Clearly I’m missing something. I cannot figure this out myself. You need to show me.
At the time, I even spoke to myself harshly and told God I must be too stupid to figure it out.
I don’t believe that about myself today.
I wasn’t stupid.
I simply couldn’t see what I hadn’t yet learned how to see.
But that prayer became a turning point in my life.
I stopped asking only for the pain to go away.
I started looking for what I needed to understand.
And eventually one realization kept appearing:
This is unhealthy.
Then another.
And another.
Suddenly experiences that had looked completely unrelated began connecting.
Not because God handed me a clinical diagnosis.
Not because every painful memory contained some secret message.
But because, through my faith, I began looking at my life differently.
And once my lens changed, I started seeing patterns I couldn’t see before.
Maybe the Question Isn’t Only “What Happened to You?”
“What happened to you?” is an incredibly important question.
Sometimes it may be the first compassionate question anyone has ever asked someone who has spent a lifetime hearing:
What’s wrong with you?
But I don’t think my healing could end there.
Eventually I needed another question:
What did what happened teach you?
And then:
Is it still true?
Maybe someone taught me that another person’s anger meant I had done something wrong.
Is that true?
Maybe I learned that being misunderstood meant I needed to explain myself until someone agreed with me.
Is that true?
Maybe I learned that love meant tolerating unhealthy behavior.
Is that true?
Maybe I learned that setting a boundary meant I was selfish.
Is that true?
Maybe I learned that someone leaving meant I wasn’t worth staying for.
Is that true?
Those questions began separating yesterday from today.
Today Gets to Be Today
Perhaps this is the simplest definition I have for what healing eventually became for me:
My mind stopped automatically believing it was fighting yesterday while I was standing in today.
Something happens now.
I deal with what happened now.
I don’t automatically pull twenty years of evidence into the room with me.
I don’t need every person to understand me.
I don’t need to explain myself endlessly.
I don’t assume someone’s mood belongs to me.
I don’t believe every uncomfortable feeling means I’m unsafe.
And when something truly is unhealthy, I don’t need to convince myself to tolerate it simply to prove that I’m healed.
I can recognize it.
Make a decision.
And move forward.
This Is My Experience, Not Everyone’s Prescription
I want to be careful about one thing.
My healing journey is not a clinical treatment protocol.
I cannot tell another person that therapy, medication, DBT, trauma-focused therapy, EMDR, grounding, faith—or anything else—will or won’t work for them.
Different people have different histories, diagnoses, biology, circumstances, resources and needs.
People with BPD can heal.
People with PTSD can heal.
People with CPTSD can improve.
People can have overlapping conditions.
And good mental-health care requires far more nuance than reducing someone’s entire experience to a social-media diagnosis.
I can only tell you what I discovered in my own life.
Talking helped me.
Validation helped me.
Coping helped me.
Therapy helped me.
But eventually I needed something more.
I needed to stop looking only at the individual rubber bands.
I needed to understand the ball.
I needed to follow the alarm backward.
I needed to understand what my mind had learned.
I needed to identify what was healthy and what wasn’t.
I needed to recognize what belonged to other people and what belonged to me.
I needed to take responsibility for the unhealthy things I had carried forward without condemning myself for learning them in the first place.
And through all of it, I needed God.
That is where healing changed for me.
I stopped asking only:
How do I survive this trigger?
And started asking:
Why is my mind sounding the alarm?
Then:
Where did it learn that?
And finally:
Is what it learned still true?
Sometimes the answer was no.
And every time my mind learned that answer, another rubber band came loose.
Until eventually, memories that once felt like emergencies became memories.
Yesterday became yesterday.
And today finally got to be today.
Shared from lived experience, not expert advice.
Healing Unlayered 
Leave a comment